Lindsey v. Hammond Kentucky Court of Appeals child support imputed income analysis
|

Lindsey v. Hammond: Did the Court Get the Age Three Child Support Rule Right?

Lindsey v. Hammond Kentucky Court of Appeals child support imputed income analysis

Key takeaways. In Lindsey v. Hammond, No. 2025-CA-1063-MR, rendered November 20, 2026, the Kentucky Court of Appeals held that the child support rule in KRS 403.212(3)(e)1. barring imputed income for a voluntarily underemployed parent caring for a child age three or younger ends on the child’s fourth birthday.

  • The Court vacated the part of a Jefferson Family Court child support order that kept applying the exception after the child turned four, and remanded for recalculation.
  • It affirmed that modified support runs back to the date the motion to modify was filed.
  • It presumed a support worksheet missing from the appellate record supported the shared parenting deviation.
  • The opinion is designated not to be published, so it is not binding precedent.

Kentucky’s child support guidelines let a court base support on imputed income, meaning what a parent could earn, not only on what the parent actually earns. There is one important exception: a court may not find a parent voluntarily underemployed, and may not impute income to that parent, while the parent is caring for a very young child. In Lindsey v. Hammond, the Court of Appeals answered a practical question about that exception. When the child turns four, does the protection stop? The panel said yes. The more interesting question, and the one this post takes up, is whether the Court’s answer gives families and trial judges a rule they can actually use.

What was Lindsey v. Hammond about?

Lindsey v. Hammond was a child support modification between two parents who share joint custody and equal parenting time of one child born in 2021. The father had been paying the mother $300 per month under an order from an earlier paternity case. In June 2023 he petitioned for shared parenting and a modification of support, and his motion to modify was filed in July 2023.

After a hearing, the Jefferson Family Court (Judge Lori N. Goodwin) entered an order on October 16, 2024, finding that both parents had chosen to be voluntarily underemployed. It set the father’s gross income at $4,225 per month and the mother’s at $11,845.83, and it ordered the mother to pay the father $175.72 per month.

The mother moved to alter, amend, or vacate under CR 59.05. The family court heard that motion in November 2024 but did not rule until July 22, 2025. In that order it set the parents’ incomes at $3,356.59 and $7,682.13, accounted for insurance and the mother’s work related child care, and found that the father would owe the mother only $5 per month. Because that amount was nominal, the court relied on KRS 403.212(6) and ordered neither parent to pay, and it vacated the mother’s $175.72 obligation back to the start of the case. The father, representing himself, appealed.

What did the Kentucky Court of Appeals decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded. Judge Lisa P. Jones wrote the opinion for a unanimous panel that also included Judges Acree and Moynahan. The full opinion is available on the Kentucky Court of Justice website.

The panel decided three issues:

  1. The age three exception. KRS 403.212(3)(e)1. provides that a finding of voluntary underemployment and a determination of potential income “shall not be made for a parent who is . . . caring for a very young child, age three (3) or younger, for whom the parents owe a joint legal responsibility.” The panel held that the family court properly declined to impute income to the mother while the child was three, but that the exception ended on the child’s fourth birthday, May 18, 2025. From that date, the income imputed to the mother “must be included in her income for purposes of calculating child support.” The Court vacated the order to the extent it failed to do that.
  2. Retroactivity. The father argued that support installments vest when due and cannot be modified before a motion is filed. The panel agreed with that rule, citing Gibson v. Gibson, 211 S.W.3d 601 (Ky. App. 2006), but found the family court followed it, because the modification ran back only to the July 2023 motion. The Court noted that the order’s reference to July 26 rather than July 6 was likely a typographical error.
  3. The shared parenting credit. The father argued the order ignored the 50/50 schedule. The panel pointed to language in the order preserving the earlier shared parenting deviation and, because the support worksheet was not in the appellate record, presumed the missing worksheet supported the ruling under Brannock v. Brannock, 598 S.W.3d 91 (Ky. App. 2019).

Why did the Court only review for manifest injustice?

Because the father’s brief did not include proper preservation statements, the Court limited its review to palpable error resulting in manifest injustice. RAP 32(A)(4) requires each argument to begin with a statement showing where and how the issue was preserved in the trial court. The father’s statements described the family court’s rulings rather than what he did to preserve the errors. Relying on Hallis v. Hallis, 328 S.W.3d 694 (Ky. App. 2010), and Ford v. Commonwealth, 628 S.W.3d 147 (Ky. 2021), the panel chose manifest injustice review rather than striking the brief. Even under that demanding standard, the father won part of his appeal.

Did the Court get it right?

On the statute, the answer looks like yes. The text of KRS 403.212(3)(e)1. protects a parent caring for a child “age three (3) or younger.” A four year old is not age three or younger. The panel did not stretch the exception, and it did not read in a grace period the General Assembly did not write. If you believe statutes mean what they say, the core holding is hard to fault.

The harder questions are about timing and process, and reasonable lawyers could see them differently.

Does support change automatically on a fourth birthday?

The opinion’s logic suggests that once a court finds a parent voluntarily underemployed and declines to impute income only because of the age three exception, the calculation for any period after the fourth birthday must include the imputed income. Here that made sense, because the family court ruled in July 2025, two months after the child turned four, and was setting support for a period that crossed the birthday. The opinion does not address what happens in a case where the order was entered before the birthday and no one files a new motion. Kentucky law generally requires a motion and a material change before support is modified, and nothing in Lindsey purports to change that. Practitioners should not read the opinion as creating an automatic adjustment.

Was the eight month delay part of the problem?

The CR 59.05 motion was heard in November 2024, when the child was three, and decided in July 2025, when the child was four. Had the ruling come promptly, the exception would have applied to the entire period then before the court. The delay is what put the birthday in the middle of the calculation. The opinion does not criticize the family court for the timing, and it did not need to, but it is a real world reminder that the facts can change while a motion sits under submission.

Is the missing worksheet presumption fair to a pro se parent?

The father’s shared parenting argument lost largely because the worksheet the order referenced was not attached and was not in the record. Under Brannock, the appellant bears responsibility for a complete record, and missing parts are presumed to support the trial court. That rule is long settled, and the panel applied it correctly. Still, it means a self represented parent can lose an argument about a document he never saw in the record. Whether that is the right allocation of the burden is a fair debate; what is not debatable is that it is the rule.

Our view: the panel read the statute correctly and applied established appellate rules faithfully. The opinion’s practical value lies in what it signals to trial courts setting support for periods that cross a child’s fourth birthday, and its limits lie in what it leaves unsaid about orders entered before that birthday.

What happens next in the case?

On remand, the family court must enter a new child support order that includes the mother’s imputed income for the period beginning May 18, 2025. The opinion does not say what the new number should be, and it would be speculation to guess whether the recalculated amount will clear the nominal threshold the family court relied on. Unless a party seeks rehearing or discretionary review, the opinion becomes final under the appellate rules and the case returns to Jefferson Family Court.

What does Lindsey v. Hammond mean for other Kentucky families?

Because the opinion is not to be published, it is not binding precedent; under RAP 41 it may be cited for consideration only when no published opinion adequately addresses the issue. Even so, it is a clear reading of a common statute. For the family law practitioner’s perspective on what this means for parents paying or receiving support, see Bowman Legal’s guide, what happens to Kentucky child support when your youngest child turns four. If you think a family court misapplied the guidelines in your case, our overview of Kentucky child support appeals and the Kentucky appeals process explains how review works and why deadlines matter.

Frequently asked questions about Lindsey v. Hammond

What did Lindsey v. Hammond hold?

The Kentucky Court of Appeals held that the exception in KRS 403.212(3)(e)1., which bars imputing income to a voluntarily underemployed parent caring for a child age three or younger, ends on the child’s fourth birthday. After that date, imputed income must be included in the child support calculation.

Is Lindsey v. Hammond binding precedent in Kentucky?

No. The opinion is designated not to be published. Under RAP 41, an unpublished Kentucky opinion may be cited for consideration only when no published opinion adequately addresses the issue.

Can a Kentucky court impute income to a stay at home parent?

Yes, if the court finds the parent voluntarily unemployed or underemployed, unless an exception applies. One exception covers a parent caring for a child age three or younger for whom both parents share legal responsibility.

How far back can a Kentucky child support modification go?

Only to the date the motion to modify was filed. Installments that came due before the motion are vested and cannot be changed, as the Court reaffirmed in Lindsey, citing Gibson v. Gibson.

What happens if the child support worksheet is missing from the appellate record?

The Court of Appeals presumes that missing parts of the record support the trial court’s ruling. In Lindsey, that presumption defeated the father’s argument about the shared parenting credit.

About the author. Jason A. Bowman is a Kentucky family law and appellate attorney and the founder of Bowman Legal in Louisville. He is a Fellow of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, has been named to Super Lawyers, and has been involved in hundreds of appeals. This analysis is written by a practicing Kentucky appellate attorney for general information; it is not legal advice. Read the full opinion and consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Published November 20, 2026. Last reviewed November 20, 2026.

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *