Kentucky Court of Appeals opinions released November 20, 2026, Judge Got It Wrong featured image with Bowman Legal Appeals logo
|

Kentucky Court of Appeals Opinions Released November 20, 2026

Key takeaways. Three Kentucky family law opinions came down on Friday, November 20, 2026, among the 14 opinions the Kentucky Court of Appeals released that morning (Minutes Nos. 737 through 750). One opinion was designated for publication, and the Court also announced 27 orders, five of them in family cases.

  • In Lindsey v. Hammond, the Court held that the rule against imputing income to a parent caring for a child age three or younger stops applying on the child’s fourth birthday.
  • In A.F.D. v. Cabinet and M.A.T. v. Cabinet, the Court affirmed the termination of both parents’ rights on Anders briefs.
  • In an order in A.A. v. Hon. Lauren Adams Ogden, the Court denied a writ but kept a child with his adoptive parents while they appeal an order setting aside the adoption.
  • In the published James v. Longley, a criminal court’s self defense immunity ruling does not decide the victim’s civil lawsuit.
  • In Rains v. Rains, the Court sent an opinion to Bar Counsel after finding miscited cases and a fabricated quotation in a brief.

As always, each case name below links to the full opinion on the Kentucky Court of Justice website.

Every Friday at 10:00 a.m., the Kentucky Court of Appeals releases its new opinions through its published minutes. Below is everything that came down today, with the family law cases first. Keep in mind that an unpublished opinion is not binding authority; under RAP 41 it may be cited only for consideration when no published opinion adequately addresses the issue.

Which Kentucky family law opinions came down today?

Lindsey v. Hammond, No. 2025-CA-1063-MR (Jefferson Family Court) | Affirmed in Part, Vacated in Part, and Remanded | Unpublished

Two parents with joint custody and equal parenting time litigated child support for two years. The family court found both voluntarily underemployed but, on a CR 59.05 motion decided eight months after it was heard, declined to impute income to the mother because she was caring for a child age three or younger, and ended her support obligation. The Court of Appeals held that the exception in KRS 403.212(3)(e)1. ends on the child’s fourth birthday; from that date forward the mother’s imputed income has to be counted, so the support order was vacated in part and sent back for recalculation. The Court affirmed the rest, including the retroactive start date, and presumed that a support worksheet missing from the appellate record supported the shared parenting deviation. Both parents represented themselves, and because the father’s brief lacked proper preservation statements under RAP 32(A)(4), the Court reviewed only for manifest injustice. Read our full analysis of Lindsey v. Hammond.

A.F.D. v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, No. 2026-CA-0594-ME (Logan Circuit Court) | Affirmed | Unpublished

The Cabinet removed a two year old from a home covered in animal waste and trash, with no running water. Fourteen months later the home still had no running water and a roach infestation, and the parents had missed 28 of 42 weekly visits. Appointed counsel filed an Anders brief, and after its own review the Court affirmed the termination under KRS 625.090(2)(e), the ground for a parent who for at least six months has failed to provide essential care with no reasonable expectation of improvement. Only one statutory ground is needed. Counsel was allowed to withdraw.

M.A.T. v. Cabinet for Health and Family Services, No. 2026-CA-0633-ME (Logan Circuit Court) | Affirmed | Unpublished

This is the father’s companion appeal on the same record. The Court affirmed for the same reasons and granted his counsel’s motion to withdraw.

A.A. v. Hon. Lauren Adams Ogden, Nos. 2026-CA-0906-OA and 2026-CA-0940-ME (Jefferson Family Court) | Order Denying Writ and Granting Intermediate Relief

A couple adopted a baby who has lived with them since birth. Months after the adoption judgment, a man who said he had been told the child died proved he was the biological father and moved to set the adoption aside under CR 60.02. Without an evidentiary hearing, the family court granted his motion as summary judgment, vacated the adoption, and ordered the child transferred to him within ten days. The Court of Appeals denied the writ because the adoptive parents have an adequate remedy in their direct appeal, but it granted intermediate relief under RAP 21: the child stays with the adoptive parents until that appeal is decided. The merits appeal is one to watch.

Other family orders

In Singh v. Singh, No. 2026-CA-0112-ME (Fayette), a domestic violence appeal, the Court had earlier ruled that the Anders no merit brief procedure does not apply to DVO appeals, and it dismissed the appeal when no merits brief followed. Keller v. Gouin, No. 2025-CA-1295-MR, Warner v. Isles-Warner, No. 2026-CA-0066-MR, and J.B.S. v. L.M.B., Nos. 2026-CA-0796-ME and 0797-ME, all from Jefferson Family Court, were dismissed because no proper appellant’s brief was filed.

Which opinion did the Kentucky Court of Appeals designate for publication?

None of today’s family law opinions made the publication list, but this one matters to anyone whose case involves both a criminal charge and a civil claim from the same incident.

James v. Longley, No. 2025-CA-0625-MR (Jefferson Circuit Court) | Affirmed in Part, Vacated in Part, and Remanded | Published

A homeowner confronted an excavator operator over dirt piled near his trees and was pushed. In the criminal case, after the Commonwealth moved to dismiss and made no argument on probable cause, the district court found the operator immune from prosecution under KRS 503.085. The circuit court treated that finding as binding in the homeowner’s civil suit. The Court of Appeals disagreed. KRS 503.085 does not make a criminal immunity ruling decide the civil case, and collateral estoppel does not apply because the injured person was not a party to the prosecution and had no full and fair chance to litigate. The trial court must decide civil immunity on its own under the summary judgment standard. A vicarious liability claim against the excavation company was also revived.

What other civil opinions did the Kentucky Court of Appeals release?

Rains v. Rains, No. 2025-CA-1347-MR (Whitley Circuit Court) | Affirmed | Unpublished

A daughter in law who built a house on her in laws’ land, knowing they owned it, could not recover for unjust enrichment, and their alleged oral promise to deed her the land is barred by the statute of frauds. The bigger story is the brief: the Court found four improper citations, including a quotation that does not appear in the cited case, and directed that the opinion be sent to the Kentucky Bar Association’s Office of Bar Counsel. Judge Taylor concurred in result only.

Nilest v. Kusyo, No. 2025-CA-0348-MR (Jefferson Circuit Court) | Reversed | Unpublished

A summary judgment piercing an LLC’s veil was reversed because the trial court relied on the members’ failure to follow formalities without applying KRS 275.185(4), which says a failure to keep required records is not a ground for member liability.

Shuler v. Fincastle Heights Mutual Ownership Corp., No. 2025-CA-1043-MR (Jefferson) | Vacated and Remanded | Unpublished

The Court vacated a judgment for a Louisville housing cooperative over a dissent by Judge Eckerle. The opinion was not yet available on the court’s website when the minutes were released.

Other civil appeals, all affirmed

Which criminal and postconviction opinions did the Kentucky Court of Appeals decide?

What orders did the Court enter?

Frequently asked questions about Kentucky family law appeals

When does the Kentucky Court of Appeals release opinions?

The Court releases opinions on Fridays at 10:00 a.m. through its published minutes, which list every opinion and order released that week.

Can a Kentucky court impute income to a parent who stays home with a young child?

Not while the child is three or younger, if the parents share legal responsibility for the child. KRS 403.212(3)(e)1. bars a finding of voluntary underemployment in that situation. As Lindsey v. Hammond shows, the protection ends on the child’s fourth birthday, and a support calculation that spans that date may need to treat the two periods differently.

Can an adoption be set aside after the judgment is entered?

A parent may ask under CR 60.02, but the stakes are high and the procedure matters. In the A.A. order, the Court of Appeals kept the child with the adoptive parents while it reviews a family court order that set the adoption aside without an evidentiary hearing.

Does a criminal self defense immunity ruling end a related civil case?

No. Under the published James v. Longley, the civil court must decide immunity on its own, and the injured person is not bound by the ruling in a criminal case he was not a party to.

What happens if a brief cites cases for things they do not say?

The Court of Appeals checks. In Rains v. Rains, it found four improper citations, including a fabricated quotation, and referred the opinion to Bar Counsel. Every citation needs to be read and verified before filing.

Need help with a Kentucky family law appeal?

We round up Kentucky family law opinions every Friday. In the meantime, you can read our November 13 roundup. If you believe a Kentucky family court got your case wrong, act quickly, because appeal deadlines are short and strictly enforced. You can learn more about Kentucky family law appeals at Bowman Legal or call (502) 861-7414.

About the author. Jason A. Bowman is a Kentucky family law and appellate attorney and the founder of Bowman Legal in Louisville. He is a Fellow of the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, has been named to Super Lawyers, and has been involved in hundreds of appeals. The summaries above are for general information and are not legal advice; read the full opinion and consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *